The Epistemological Analysis of the Spiritual Feats of Sheikh Ahmad-e Jam “The Colossal Elephant” (Zhandeh Pil)

Rezaei, Amin; Poornamdarian, Taghi; Mohammadnezhad Alizamini, Yousef

doi:10.22051/jml.2021.35411.2176

Document Type : Scientific-research

Authors

¹ PhD student of Persian Language and Literature, Institute for Humanities and Cultural Studies, Tehran, Iran

² Professor of Persian Language and Literature, Institute for Humanities and Cultural Studies, Tehran, Iran

³ Assistant Professor of Persian Language and Literature. Institute for Humanities and Cultural Studies, Tehran, Iran

https://doi.org/10.22051/jml.2021.35411.2176

Abstract

The concept of episteme and the means of achieving it in Sufi texts and writings have always been among the important thinking priorities of Sufi writers and luminaries. Furthermore, the issue of supernatural wonders or miraculous acts performed by Sufi spiritual masters (Karāmāt) is regarded as one of the most evident aspects of their manners and has come to be known as a true test and criterion for assessing the spiritual status of the saintly people. This research aims to answer these two questions: What is knowledge/episteme in Sheikh-e Jam’s view? And what is the connection between Sheikh Ahmad-e Jam's distinguishing supernatural wonders, i.e. transformation of the essence (qalb-e jowhar), and the definition of epistemology in his school of thought? To that aim, first, the status and definition of epistemology in the texts of Sufism are examined and then, the definition of the same concept in Sheikh-e Jam's writings and the features of knowledge and episteme in his works are explicated. Based on his writings, we can safely assume that Sheikh-e Jam thinks of knowledge as the elixir (as in alchemy) which leads to the transformation of the mystic's nature; he is also of the belief that achieving this knowledge coincides with gaining a special power to interfere with the essence of the objects. Then, the significance of the “transformation of the essence” in Sheikh-e Jam's writings and its connection with the doctrines of Karamiyya Islamic sect will be investigated. After these three introductions, the connection between the miraculous acts of Sheikh-e Jam and his specific epistemological stance will be illuminated. In view of that, the logic of narrating such spiritual feats will make sense in the field of contrastive discourse, beyond that of forgery and fabrication.

Keywords

References

References

Ansari, M. A. (2006). Tabaqat al-Sufiyya [Generations of Sufis] (M. Sarvar Molaei, Ed.). Toos Publications.

Badvi, A. R. (2010). Tarikhe tassawufe Islami [History of Islamic Sufism] (M. R. Eftekharzadeh, Trans.). Afraz Publications.

Bahmani Motlaq, Y., & Khodadadi, M. (2010). Analysis of thoughts and introduction of Sheikh Ahmad Jam’s works. Religions and Mysticism, 6(24), 115-136.

Daei al-Hassani Razi, S. M. (1985). Tabserat al-avam fi ma’refate maqalat al-anam [Enlightening the laymen on knowledge of the sayings of the creatures] (A. Iqbal, Ed.). Asatir Publications.

Ebrahimi Dinani, Gh. H. (2004). Mantiq va ma’refat dar nazare Ghazali [Logic and episteme in Ghazali’s view]. Amirkabir Publications.

Fan, S. Y. (1992). Texts about Karamiyya (A. Shafi’i, Trans.). Ma’aref, (25), 34–118.

Ghazali, M. (2011). Kimiyaye sa’adat [The alchemy of happiness] (H. Khadiv Jam, Ed.). Elmi-Farhangi Publishing Company.

Ghaznavi, S. M. (1961). Maghamate Zhande Pil [The statuses of Zhande Pil] (H. Moayed Sanandaji, Ed.). Book Translation and Publishing Company.

Ghorbanpour Arani, H., & Heidari Ramsheh, N. (2014). From miracles to superstitions: With a focus on Asrar al-towhid and Maghamat-e Ahmade Jam. Religions and Mysticism, 47(2), 301–332.

Hamadani, E. Q. (2000). Zobdat al-haqayeq [The quintessence of truth] (A. Asiran, Ed. & M. Tadayon, Trans.). University Publishing Center.

Hamadani, E. Q. (2010). Tamhidat [Preludes] (A. Asiran, Ed.). Manouchehri Publications.

Hujwiri, A. A. (2013). Kashf ul-mahjoob [Revelation of the veiled] (M. Abedi, Ed.). Soroush Publications.

Jam Namqi, A. (1968). Meftah al-nejat [The key to salvation] (A. Fazel, Ed.). Iranian Culture Foundation.

Jam Namqi, A. (1971). Ons al-ta’ibin and seratullah al-mubin [Penitents’ companionship and the true path of God] (A. Fazel, Ed.). Iranian Culture Foundation.

Jam Namqi, A. (2008). Konuz al-hikmah [Treasure of wisdom] (A. Fazel, Ed.). Institute for Humanities and Cultural Studies.

Jam Namqi, A. (2010). Siraj al-sayerin [The light for others] (H. Nasiri Jami, Ed.). Institute for Humanities and Cultural Studies.

Javadi, M., & Mo’azami Goodarzi, A. (2007). The epistemological status of mystical intuition. Quarterly Journal of Religious Thought, 7(25), 91-116.

Madani, A. H. (2012). Ahmad Jam: From myth to truth. Mystical Studies, 1(16), 217-240.

Madani, A. H., Kahdoei, M. K., & Malik Sabet, M. (2010). Sheikh Ahmad Jām and the fiction of his charismas. Journal of Adab Pazhuhi (Persian Language and Literature), 4 (13), 85–108.

Maki, A. (2001). Qut al-qolub fi moamelat al-mahboub [The nourishment of hearts in dealing with the beloved] (M. I. M. al-Rezvani, Ed.). Maktabat al-Torath.

Mastali Parsa, Gh., & Shams, H. (2014). Power and spiritual reign of holy fathers in opinion of Sheikh Ahmad Jām. Literary Text Research, 18(62), 59-80.

Mattha, F. (2012). Ghazali and the Ismailis (F. Badrehi, Trans.) Farzan Rooz.

Mehrabani, A., & Heidari, H. (2010). A mystical type of Gnosis and faith. Mystical Studies, 1 (11), 247–272.

Munavvar, M. (2009). Asrar al-towhid fi maqamate Sheikh Abusaeed [Secrets of monotheism in the statuses of Sheikh Abusaeed] (M. R. Shafiei Kadkani, Ed.). Agah Publications.

Mustamli Bukhari, A. I. (2010). Sharh at-ta'arruf li-madhhab at-tasawwuf [The doctrine of the Sufis] (M. Roshan, Ed.). Asatir Publications.

Noya, P. (1973). Unpublished Sufi manuscripts. Dar al-Mashriq.

Ostovar Namaghi, S. M. (2013). The levels of epistemology in Ahmad Namaghi’s viewpoint. Erfaniyat, 4 (14), 146–166.

Ostovar Namaghi, S. M., Zarghani, S. M., & Qurban Sabbagh, M. R. (2017). Analyzing the discourse in Ahmade-e Jam’s Ons al-taebin. Literary Studies, 49(1), 47–77.

Pakatchi, A. (2004). Knowledge in mystical thought of Sheikh Najm al-din. Journal of Philosophy of Religion Research, 2 (2), 15–34.

Pourjavadi, N. (2015). Daryaye ma’refat [Sea of knowledge]. Hermes Publications.

Pourmozafari, D. (2017). The macro-structure in mystical Maqamats and its ideological functions. Literary Criticism Quarterly, 10 (37), 29–58.

Pournamdarian, T. (2005). Dar saye aftab [In the shade of the sun]. Sokhan Publications.

Qushayri, A. A. (2009). Risala al-Qushayriyya [Qushayriyya treatise] (A. H. Osmani, Trans. & B. Z. Forouzanfar, Ed.). Zavar Publications.

Rahmati, M. K. (2001). Research on Keramiyeh. Monthly Journal of Religion, 7(43), 58–77.

Sahlegi, M. A. (2006). Daftare roshanayi [Book of light] (M. R. Shafiei Kadkani, Trans.). Sokhan Publications.

Sajjadi, S. A. M., Khatami, A., & Jafari, F. (2014). Comparative study of knowledge in Islamic mysticism and Gnosticism. Journal of Religious Studies, 8(15), 33–52.

Sam’ani, Sh. A. (2010). Rawh al-arwah fi sharh asma' al-malik al-fattah [The ease of spirits in explaining the names of the all-conquering king] (N. Mayel Heravi, Ed.). Elmi-Farhangi Publishing Company.

Sari Aslani, Sh. (2015). Self-knowledge in perspective of Ayn al-Quzat. Erfaniyat, 8 (29), 189–214.

Shafiee Kadkani, M. R. (2006). Nevesteh bar darya [Written on the sea]. Sokhan Publications.

Shafiee Kadkani, M. R. (2014). Darvish-e setihandeh [Combative dervish]. Sokhan Publications.

Shajari, M. (2010). Knowledge from Ayn-al-Qużāt Hamedānī's point of view. Journal of Mytho-Mystic Literature, 6(20), 85–112.

Siraj Tusi, A. N. (1960). Al-luma' fi'l-taṣawwuf [Light flashes on Sufism] (A. M. & T. A. Sarvar, Eds.). Dar al-Kotob al-Hadithah.

Tamaddon, E., & Nasr Isfahani, M. R. (2015). Recognition in mystical disposition of Ruzbihan Baqli. Mystical Literature, 8(15), 153–178.

Termazi, A. A. (2002). The depth of affairs (A. R. Sayeh & A. A. Awaz, Eds.). Religious Culture School.

Zar’ei, Z., Azar, A. I., & Sadraei, R. (2019). Manifestation of mysticism in the thought of Najm al-Din Razi. Islamic Mysticism, 15 (59), 101–122.

The Epistemological Analysis of the Spiritual Feats of Sheikh Ahmad-e Jam “The Colossal Elephant” (Zhandeh Pil)

References

References

Volume 12, Issue 23December 2020Pages 111-140

Volume 12, Issue 23
December 2020
Pages 111-140